[xx_Mandi]

I agree-alittle bit. Not all pop-punk music sucks though. For instance, both Good Charlotte and Hilary Duff's music fit right in

I can't wait until the holidays. I'll most likely be getting GC's convert DVD EEEKKK!!!! I wanna see Billy!! He's so hott!!

[nicholaaaas]

I think it's an insult to punk to even say Hil's name and punk in the same sentance. Sid Vicious would be spinning in his grave

*JuicyHD*, on Nov 17 2004, 08:52 PM, said:

I agree-alittle bit. Not all pop-punk music sucks though. For instance, both Good Charlotte and Hilary Duff's music fit right in 

I can't wait until the holidays. I'll most likely be getting GC's convert DVD  EEEKKK!!!! I wanna see Billy!! He's so hott!! 

[xx_Mandi]

I didn't say that Hilary's music was just Punk. It has a vibe of being that now, but it's more of pop still. She improved from before with her music though. Atleast she's not singing [censored]ty music like bubble gum pop or R&B

[Crazy4Lindsay]

although, nicholaaaas, i and many other people would regard referring to good charlotte as punk insulting... they are just pop music. and BAD pop music. pop with pretensions.

[baturkin17]

neither , they both suck.

[gregair13]

i dont think green day and bad charolette should even be in the same poll. green day is like one of the first punk bands ever. gc is new and hasnt had the time in the business that green day has had.

[nicholaaaas]

Actually I was saying that saying HD was punk was insulting. I have actually seen GC long like 7 years ago before they were famous and they were punk...ish back then. Not so much/at all now. And to Gregair Green Day one of the first punk bands? Ever hear of The Sex Pistols, Black Flag, Dead Kennedys?

Crazy4Lindsay, on Nov 18 2004, 11:48 AM, said:

although, nicholaaaas, i and many other people would regard referring to good charlotte as punk insulting... they are just pop music. and BAD pop music. pop with pretensions.

[xbrandnewxsnowx]

HAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHA GC? LMFAO! Ok anyways wow. Lets just buy a stick of eye liner and shove in on are faces. I mean come on. They come out with this goth appearance and then turn out to be some [censored]y a[censored] pop band. I mean, come on.

Green Day all the way. Want to know why? Check out Minority, Basket Case, Brain Stew, or Hitchin a Ride. All sweet songs.

[Oasis_Mudvayner]

gregair13, on Nov 18 2004, 04:35 PM, said:

i dont think green day and bad charolette should even be in the same poll. green day is like one of the first punk bands ever. gc is new and hasnt had the time in the business that green day has had.

haha, when it comes to music styles they are probably one of the most compared two. I remember seeing a interview with GC's lead singer and he said that he made this band cause they wanted to be like Green Day. I could be mistaking, thought, it was a long time ago

anyway, i voted for Good Charlotte cause Green Day kinda faded out a bit /completely my opinion, i don't want anybody do accept it/. I haven't heard something interesting from them except "American Idiot"

[Geoff]

i like both but Green Day is definately better than GC

[marius]

Green Day

[lazylizard]

green day all the way

my best friend listens to GC, and i don't get how she can listen to it, it stinks

[lazylizard]

hey green day fans! Green day will be on the late show tonight

[Scoutmaster]

nah I vote for Green Day because there new single rocks

But actually if it comes to rock/punk music Linkin Park and Avril lavinge are better

That's my opinion

[someguy]

Green Day anyday. They are just much more talanted and they are incredible live. Billie Joe can actually sing well live un-like other bands ive heard/seen. but hey just my opinion.

[Trent]

Hmmm...an old thread revived...


Well, gonna vote for Good Charlotte. Green Day are good, but they were never amongst my favorite bands

[Linds_Fan]

I prefer Green day.I'm not a Fan but I like the Music more than GCs.

This post has been edited by Linds_Fan14: January 05 2005, 6:22 PM

[Crazyboy862]

I say Green Day I love their new songs American Idiot and Boulevard of Broken Dreams there's was this other song I liked it was an old song I can't remember the name of it.It went like this "I hope you have the time of your life"does anybody know what the name of the song is anwayz Green Day is awesome they're waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay better than Good Charlotte.

[RonKirk]

It's called Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)

[Crazyboy862]

RonKirk, on Jan 7 2005, 09:55 PM, said:

It's called Good Riddance (Time of Your Life)

thanks RON